Insufficiency fracture

Changed by Daniel J Bell, 7 Mar 2019

Updates to Article Attributes

Body was changed:

Show markup changes

Insufficiency fractures are a type of stress fracture, which are the result of normal stresses on abnormal bone. They should not be confused with fatigue fractures which are due to abnormal stresses on normal bone, or with pathological fractures, the result of diseased, weakened bone due to focal pathology such as tumours (both malignant and benign).

Epidemiology

In general, they are seen in the elderly, more frequently in women ².

Pathology

They are most often seen in the setting of osteoporosis, although any process which weakens bone is a risk factor. Long-term bisphosphonate use has also been associated with insufficiency fractures ⁵.

Aetiology

Osteoporosis is the most common cause of insufficiency fractures, although there are many more ^7-9:

disrupted bone mineral homeostasis: osteoporosis, hyperparathyroidism, diabetes mellitus, osteomalacia
bone remodelling: Paget disease, osteopetrosis
collagen formation: Marfan syndrome, fibrous dysplasia
medications: glucocorticoids, chemotherapy
radiation therapy

Location

vertebral (crush or wedge) fractures: very common.
- marrow oedema is limited to the vertebral body; extension of abnormal signal into the pedicles suggests an underlying lesion
sacrum: HHonda sign
neck of femur
proximal third femur (see article: bisphosphonate-related proximal femur fractures) ⁵
pubic rami
sternum ³
fibula ⁶
tibia ⁶

Radiographic features

Early diagnosis is best made with bone scan or MRI, as plain films may initially appear normal.

Plain radiograph

initially normal
periosteal reaction progressing to callus formation in diaphyseal fractures
linear sclerosis and cortical thickening more frequent in metaphyseal and epiphyseal fractures ²

MRI

MRI is as sensitive as bone scanning, with the added benefit of higher specificity, both in isolating the exact anatomic location and in distinguishing fractures from tumours or infection.

T1: low marrow signal
T2: high marrow signal with extension into adjacent soft tissues
C+ (Gd): enhancement can be intense

Nuclear medicine

On bone scan, there is increased activity at the site of the fracture.

Treatment and prognosis

Treatment depends on the location and whether the fracture is complete or incomplete. Options, therefore, include:

conservative management
plaster cast
internal fixation
vertebroplasty
kyphoplasty

Treatment of the underlying cause of bone weakness is also essential.

-<li>disrupted bone mineral homeostasis: <a href="/articles/osteoporosis">osteoporosis</a>, <a title="Hyperparathyroidism" href="/articles/hyperparathyroidism">hyperparathyroidism</a>, <a title="Diabetes mellitus" href="/articles/diabetes-mellitus">diabetes mellitus</a>, <a title="Osteomalacia" href="/articles/osteomalacia">osteomalacia</a>
+<li>disrupted bone mineral homeostasis: <a href="/articles/osteoporosis">osteoporosis</a>, <a href="/articles/hyperparathyroidism">hyperparathyroidism</a>, <a href="/articles/diabetes-mellitus">diabetes mellitus</a>, <a href="/articles/osteomalacia">osteomalacia</a>
~~-<li>bone remodelling: <a title="Paget disease (bone)" href="/articles/paget-disease-bone">Paget disease</a>, <a title="Osteopetrosis" href="/articles/osteopetrosis">osteopetrosis</a>~~
+<li>bone remodelling: <a href="/articles/paget-disease-bone">Paget disease</a>, <a href="/articles/osteopetrosis">osteopetrosis</a>
~~-<li>collagen formation: <a title="Marfan syndrome" href="/articles/marfan-syndrome">Marfan syndrome</a>, <a title="Fibrous dysplasia" href="/articles/fibrous-dysplasia">fibrous dysplasia</a>~~
+<li>collagen formation: <a href="/articles/marfan-syndrome">Marfan syndrome</a>, <a href="/articles/fibrous-dysplasia">fibrous dysplasia</a>
-<a href="/articles/osteoporotic-spinal-compression-fracture">vertebral (crush or wedge) fractures</a>: very common.<ul><li>marrow oedema is limited to the vertebral body; extension of abnormal signal into the pedicles suggests an underlying lesion</li></ul>
+<a href="/articles/osteoporotic-spinal-compression-fracture">vertebral (crush or wedge) fractures</a>: very common<ul><li>marrow oedema is limited to the vertebral body; extension of abnormal signal into the pedicles suggests an underlying lesion</li></ul>
~~-<li>sacrum: <a href="/articles/honda-sign-sacrum">H sign</a>~~
+<li>sacrum: <a href="/articles/honda-sign-sacrum">Honda sign</a>
~~-<li>proximal third femur (see article: <a href="/articles/bisphosphonate-related-proximal-femoral-fractures">bisphosphonate-related proximal femur fractures</a>) <sup>5</sup>~~
+<li>proximal third femur (see article: <a href="/articles/atypical-femoral-fracture-1">bisphosphonate-related proximal femur fractures</a>) <sup>5</sup>
~~-<li>plaster cast</li>~~
+<li><a title="Plaster of Paris" href="/articles/plaster-of-paris-1">plaster cast</a></li>

ADVERTISEMENT: Supporters see fewer/no ads

{"current_user":null,"inclusions":[{"imageId":2776343,"studyId":20936,"caseSlug":"pelvic-insufficiency-fractures-illustrations","caption":"Figure 1: pelvic insufficiency fractures","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/2776343/9c5c14cfd7e9ce2177060692401d21_big_gallery.jpg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"not_applicable"},{"imageId":16249,"studyId":6847,"caseSlug":"osteoporosis-steroid-induced","caption":"Case 1","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/16249/fb7cce532d81900769f453d28cb43a_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_unsubstantiated"},{"imageId":1703140,"studyId":16367,"caseSlug":"insufficiency-fracture-calcaneum","caption":"Case 2: calcaneal insufficiency fracture","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/1703140/cb1ebb5171188a9e90e18761668fff_big_gallery.jpg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"},{"imageId":1797433,"studyId":16815,"caseSlug":"insufficiency-fracture-distal-tibia","caption":"Case 3 ","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/1797433/d2a7a881db7a11a25010849a7451af_big_gallery.jpg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_unsubstantiated"},{"imageId":1828822,"studyId":17026,"caseSlug":"vertebral-insufficiency-fractures-in-severe-osteoporosis","caption":"Case 4: osteoporotic lumbar fractures","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/1828822/0a09657743865938e4022af3f5864e_big_gallery.jpg","isStack":true,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_unsubstantiated"},{"imageId":13638261,"studyId":39449,"caseSlug":"insufficiency-fracture-of-the-sternum","caption":"Case 5","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/13638261/0b4c8ef4be73321c5454c8d472e71c_big_gallery.jpg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"},{"imageId":22192986,"studyId":48858,"caseSlug":"tibial-plateau-insufficiency-fracture","caption":"Case 6: tibial plateau","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/22192986/c214e9030cfe91537e5de21f1ca609_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":null},{"imageId":23765060,"studyId":50612,"caseSlug":"bilateral-tibial-insufficiency-fractures","caption":"Case 7: bilateral on SPECT ","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/23765060/d10c985612e41660b5cde839a13491_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":true,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"},{"imageId":41259653,"studyId":70086,"caseSlug":"renal-osteodystrophy-and-insufficiency-fractures","caption":"Case 8","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/41259653/a6428c9282fa62b4f1f1421f7d3f34_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":true,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_unsubstantiated"},{"imageId":57219193,"studyId":117717,"caseSlug":"sacral-insufficiency-fracture-7","caption":"Case 9: sacral insufficiency fracture","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/57219193/37895aa2176024ac3d9aa7a267ecee863ac34ee6b3d6cf3e62c961a14f9eaac2_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":true,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"},{"imageId":62876019,"studyId":139017,"caseSlug":"insufficiency-fractures-due-to-vitamin-d-deficiency","caption":"Case 10: Insufficiency fractures due to vitamin D deficiency","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/62876019/4e6b77d496b85891fefaa31dd78afd7fddc6038e297b4f2392b462fe8ece3ac1_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"},{"imageId":63946836,"studyId":143454,"caseSlug":"x-linked-hypophosphataemia-and-looser-zone-1","caption":"Case 11: X-linked hypophosphatemia and looser zone","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/63946836/11e25c2ad42e5a1e275ef8a2e846e26526c71fb2f70be97c4408cd45c4d83ed4_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_substantiated"}],"ddx_inclusions":[{"imageId":675,"studyId":37491,"caseSlug":"calcaneal-insufficiency-fracture","caption":" Fatigue fracture","thumbnail":"https://prod-images-static.radiopaedia.org/images/675/6039bc72ae5ed90e30ee690e62500f_big_gallery.jpeg","isStack":false,"diagnosticCertainty":"confirmed_unsubstantiated"}],"lang":"us"}